After having been told off by M for 'only' wanting to talk about school with her the subject has been more acceptable lately. Some of her questions have been pretty much impossible to answer, such as 'Do you think I would like school?'. Others have been tricky in other ways. I have been trying to be as impartial as I can and just provide information so that the girls can make up their own minds, but yesterday M was very insistent on wanting to know what I wanted, and the reply that I wanted them each to do what was right for them really wasn't going to cut it. I stuck with that answer but did add that, like them, I'm not keen on change that is not of my choosing, so purely from that point of view I would prefer to continue with home ed.
This week we went for a tour of the local school with the deputy head, who seemed very pleasant. She was able to answer most of my questions, regarding streaming and support, although understandably she did not want to make any promises that may not be possible to keep. The exams were still in full flow, so it was considerably quieter than is would usually be, despite the considerable amount of building work going on. As far as the girls were concerned, it gave them a reasonable idea of the place, but very little idea of what actually going to school would be like.
We had more discussion after the visit and I told them, that they really needed to make a decision by the end of the weekend, since if they decided that they did want to go we really need to get the application in as soon as possible. I suggested we get a couple of big pieces of paper and write down all the pros and cons that we could think of for each of home education and school. Before we had made a start on this though, K announced that she had decided what she was going to do. She is going to continue with home education for another year and then is planning on either going to school or college in September 2017 (one of our local colleges has for the past few years run GCSE courses specifically for home educated teenagers, available from the equivalent of school year 9, which she will be then).
M is very conflicted and has yet to decide what to do. One of the things she has said is that she 'doesn't want not to have gone to school'. I can understand this feeling, but can't help but think it's not a particularly positive reason to want to go. Her ideal would be to try it for three weeks apparently, but A & I have said that although the choice to go to school would not mean that it was forever, we would expect her to go into it with a positive attitude that she would be giving it a really proper go. A had a talk with her about it this evening, and told her that he believes education is very important and that she should have a think about which option would be best in helping her to learn.
Having said that the girls needed to make their decision by the end of this weekend, we have said that if she can't (or won't) decide by then, then we would make the decision for her. It's really not clear cut, as the idea of school is something that probably isn't going to go away, so it's really a question of making the decision
for now. In some ways if we could sort things out quickly, this would be the ideal time to start school, since she would be starting secondary school at the same time as everyone else. On the other hand, the fact that K has decided not to go to school, means that as a family having one child in school and the other home educated would be difficult logistically and I think M would struggle greatly with the fact that she would be missing out on activities and seeing home ed friends that K would be continuing with.